tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post4483139540290288629..comments2024-02-27T03:36:20.256-07:00Comments on Krista Van Dolzer: An Agent's Inbox #20Krista Van Dolzerhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/08830193414560232842noreply@blogger.comBlogger17125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-30205141807878642452012-08-17T23:50:59.019-06:002012-08-17T23:50:59.019-06:00Thanks so much for the feedback, Agent! It's ...Thanks so much for the feedback, Agent! It's really helpful to know what seems confusing and what information is missing that would make the premise clearer. :-) Thank you for the kind remarks on the opening page, too!<br /><br />And thank you everyone else for the additional feedback! It's been really great. I appreciate it! Y'all are awesome!G.B. Skyehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13798228862436721498noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-31544594582005402372012-08-17T12:08:55.196-06:002012-08-17T12:08:55.196-06:00Oh, I really like the twist of Yuki in the premise...Oh, I really like the twist of Yuki in the premise—she’s been dead 15 years. I like the ideas here. I think the query itself could be a little more succinct and to the point. Love the title.<br /><br />Interesting to use Latin in your story; makes me wonder if it will be important later, or if Blair is just a quirky sort of guy. I’m interested to know why he jumps if it wasn’t planned, so I would keep reading for that. ;)<br />Charlie N. Holmberghttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13546802577363686054noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-53772160726686958572012-08-17T08:50:47.932-06:002012-08-17T08:50:47.932-06:00I found myself confused by this query. It took me ...I found myself confused by this query. It took me two readings of the query to understand that Blair wasn't dead when he woke up in the Styx. There's a lot that needs to be explained--the reaper, Blair's suicide, why he can't choose to go back. And since the urgency comes from his coma, I'd like it to be made clearer that he's not dead yet. I also wanted to know more about Blair. Why did he jump? Especially after I read the first page, and it became clear this wasn't intentional suicide, I found the query confusing.<br /><br />I also didn't have any emotional connection to Yuki--she seemed more creepy than anything--so it wasn't entirely clear to me why Blair would risk everything for her.<br /><br />As with the other afterlife queries we've seen this week, I worry this is too static. An island in the Styx doesn't give a lot of room for action. Is there a wider underworld Blair will explore? Does he go back to the real world? You've done a good job explaining the premise and the setting you have, but I need to see more to be convinced that this setting is an interesting place where I'd want to spend an entire book.<br /><br />I liked the first page a lot, although it felt like part of another book. I wanted to learn more about this snarky, Latin-quoting boy--I'm just not sure I want to learn about it after his death!The Agentnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-72353013743441361802012-08-17T08:15:03.940-06:002012-08-17T08:15:03.940-06:00The query made sense to me- good job explaining wh...The query made sense to me- good job explaining what sounds like a complex story. The stakes are clear as well. I'm actually pretty excited about a story like that- but the ice cream scene was almost a let-down after the query. It was normal and everyday enough that I just wasn't interested. The writing was competent and I had no problem with it- I just wasn't pulled onward. Can you find a way to add more tension and hook in that first page? Then I'd totally read more. Kate Brauninghttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17359786337276060219noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-68228604431956507302012-08-16T20:56:24.305-06:002012-08-16T20:56:24.305-06:00I like the concept! I want to know why he kills hi...I like the concept! I want to know why he kills himself, and I'd love to keep reading--your first 250 were great. I don't actually have any feedback on the query, I thought it was really good. <br />Best of luck! :) <br />Nazarea Andrewshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09644521286572844909noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-6573572599872761442012-08-16T16:22:43.910-06:002012-08-16T16:22:43.910-06:00I had no particular qualms with the query or first...I had no particular qualms with the query or first 250. Well a few really nitpicky ones that I don't think are going to make or break the submission. I find Blair's predicament to be interesting but haven't quite connected to him yet as a character. I'd read on to get more of a feel for him and to understand what pushed him over the edge. <br /><br />Warm wishes, Author,<br />Deserae Deserae McGlothenhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09181339040825589703noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-36285459176945215282012-08-16T07:02:43.584-06:002012-08-16T07:02:43.584-06:00Loved this at WriteOnCon! Good luck!Loved this at WriteOnCon! Good luck!Meredithhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/10553213541602852817noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-7676196188150862722012-08-15T18:02:58.979-06:002012-08-15T18:02:58.979-06:00I love the premise. Very intriguing and I love Gre...I love the premise. Very intriguing and I love Greek and Roman mythology. I think you might just want to explain why Blair goes to the Underworld and not Purgatory, but I may be too much of a nerd ;-) I was also wondering if there is a love story going on between Blair and Yuki and if there is then I would make it more clear as that's a selling point. I also really like the Latin quotes at the beginning (again, because I am a nerd) but I worry that it might be a little off-putting for a teen right on the first page. Anyway, great job!Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12445539873467772283noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-75790487342272571382012-08-15T17:56:49.946-06:002012-08-15T17:56:49.946-06:00I really like your concept, and I also wondered wh...I really like your concept, and I also wondered why Yuki knows a way but can't go herself, but I'm sure it's explained in your book.<br /><br />Your opening scene was good, but the Latin did stumble me a little, maybe instead of writing the "I scream..." phrase out in Latin you can just mention that there's a Latin sign that says "I scream, you sceam..." that way there's only one Latin phrase in the opening. But you know, that's kinda nitpicky and I did like the scene =)A.J. Lockehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08514343224203400113noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-88443622438493372762012-08-15T17:48:32.894-06:002012-08-15T17:48:32.894-06:00Wow! I love everything about this. The concept, th...Wow! I love everything about this. The concept, the characterization, the high stakes, the writing.<br /><br />There's no doubt in my mind I'd read on. Probably into the night and 'till dawn...<br /><br />The scene you depicted in your 250 words is really strong and sticks in my mind. <br /><br />Hats off to you, my friend, hats off. :)Kristy Shenhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15895893708061208660noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-3242385476552754802012-08-15T13:18:52.248-06:002012-08-15T13:18:52.248-06:00Very good voice in the 250. The concept is really...Very good voice in the 250. The concept is really interesting- I immediately thought of the movie What Dreams May Come, with Robin Williams traveling to the underworld to save his wife after her suicide. I was a little confused after reading in the query that he committed suicide to then get to the first line of the MS, which states that his death wasn't planned. I'm sure it gets explained as the story goes on, but it threw me a little. I also had a question within the query about his motives for going back- perhaps life in the in-between realm is so miserable that anything would be better, but didn't he just commit suicide to escape his life. Has he suddenly realized he didn't have it so bad? I picture someone who could do such a thing as being completely despondent and ambivalent about the life they chose to give up. Again, I'm sure it gets explained in the story but it might help to add a bit about it in the query so we see why he's suddenly had such a change of heart about living.... I'm intrigued though!!!Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-72324426910022706812012-08-15T12:48:21.998-06:002012-08-15T12:48:21.998-06:00I read this query on WriteOnCon this week:) I'...I read this query on WriteOnCon this week:) I'm still intrigued. <br /><br />Reading the 1st page though I got bogged down in the Latin (and I took 4 years in HS-not that I remember it 15 years later) Also, I have an ice cream counter scene in my 1st chapter with HS girls.<br /><br />Loved the gooey spoon coming back to him with saliva, caramel and marshmallow:)<br /><br />Good Luck!Robinhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09462486350293703991noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-9883319589946748742012-08-15T12:44:16.202-06:002012-08-15T12:44:16.202-06:00Definitely intrigued! Query reads well, but think ...Definitely intrigued! Query reads well, but think it would benefit if tighter. I agree with Delia - I think it would flow better if you changed the second line of the query to something like 'Unfortunately, the grim reaper won't take him, because there are different rules for suicides.'<br /><br />And I'm also confused why Yuki can't leave if she knows a way...is it because she's been dead for so long? Was she also a suicide? <br /><br />I would definitely have kept reading past the 250 words - only thing that stopped me was the Latin phrase when he hands her the ice cream. For a second I thought we were in some alternate world with a language other than English, and that thought took me out of your story.CallMeKarmahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07147131532747663680noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-22480333885158043252012-08-15T12:22:08.699-06:002012-08-15T12:22:08.699-06:00I really like that query, it sparks interest and t...I really like that query, it sparks interest and tells a lot without giving away too much. I would read the novel.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03586364763465652747noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-7176601793147850032012-08-15T10:44:40.253-06:002012-08-15T10:44:40.253-06:00Hi GBS! I really like this, and unfortunately don...Hi GBS! I really like this, and unfortunately don't have anything constructive to add. To me you do a nice job of setting up the plot and the stakes, and the concept feels like on I haven't seen before. Your first 250 do a nice job of introducing me to your character, and your opening line leaves me curious to know what exactly happens to lead to his "fatal leap." Nice job.SStokeshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03607391693287377280noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-38225357530096027352012-08-15T10:10:41.585-06:002012-08-15T10:10:41.585-06:00Oops. I meant to say Hi, GBS! How embarrassing. So...Oops. I meant to say Hi, GBS! How embarrassing. Sorry, GBS!Deliahttp://delia-moran.blogspot.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4250988928163509961.post-19647319868193754392012-08-15T10:06:46.520-06:002012-08-15T10:06:46.520-06:00Hi Krista! I like this. It's an interesting co...Hi Krista! I like this. It's an interesting concept, but I'm left with a few questions. The biggest is, if Yuki knows a way back, why doesn't she take it herself? I'm sure it's explained in the book, but I don't think it would hurt to put it in the query. <br /><br />At the beginning of the query, you say the grim reaper won't take him and I immediately wonder why. I think it would serve you better to move the explanation (he's a suicide) closer to the original statement. <br /><br />Oh also, there's a latin word for mall? And is the footnote thing something that's continued throughout the book, or just the once? Or did you just do that for our benefit? If it's a continued thing, nice. I like how you're playing with form. If not, you might reconsider whether you can work it into the text.<br /><br />I really do like the tone you've set, with the bored, condescendingly aloof kid. He seems far from the type who'd pitch himself off a bridge, which bears out your first line. Very nice.<br /><br />Best of luck!Deliahttp://delia-moran.blogspot.comnoreply@blogger.com